#1: Progressive Commercial — Best Overall for Owner-Operators
Progressive Commercial dominates the trucking insurance market for owner-operators because they combine competitive pricing with the fastest quoting process in the industry. Their online quoting tool generates a bindable quote in under 30 minutes — compared to the 3-7 day wait typical of traditional trucking insurance agencies. For new authority holders who need proof of insurance to activate their MC number, this speed is critical. Progressive also accepts new authority risks that many carriers refuse, making them the go-to for first-time owner-operators.
Coverage options include primary auto liability ($750,000 or $1,000,000 limits as required by FMCSA), physical damage, motor truck cargo (up to $250,000 per occurrence), non-trucking liability, bobtail coverage, and trailer interchange. Premiums for a clean-record owner-operator with new authority typically run $14,000-$22,000/year for a standard liability and cargo package. Experienced operators with two or more years of authority and clean CSA scores can see rates as low as $9,000-$14,000/year.
Pros: Fastest quoting in the industry, accepts new authority applicants, competitive pricing for clean records, strong online account management, nationwide coverage, multiple deductible options for physical damage. Cons: Claims handling can be slow during peak periods, rate increases at renewal can be significant if you file claims, limited flexibility on custom coverage structures. Best for solo owner-operators, especially those with new authority, who want affordable coverage from a financially stable carrier. See /reviews/insurance-companies/ for detailed Progressive analysis.
#2: National Indemnity (Berkshire Hathaway) — Best Financial Stability
National Indemnity, a Berkshire Hathaway subsidiary, offers trucking insurance backed by the strongest balance sheet in the insurance industry. For owner-operators concerned about their insurer's ability to pay large claims — and you should be, given that nuclear verdicts in trucking regularly exceed $10 million — National Indemnity's financial backing provides certainty that no small or mid-size insurer can match. An A++ AM Best rating is the highest possible financial strength rating.
Their trucking division provides primary liability, cargo, physical damage, and general liability coverage designed for for-hire carriers. Premiums are not the cheapest — expect to pay 5-15% more than Progressive or Canal for comparable coverage. The premium difference buys you claims handling that is consistently professional and responsive, underwriters who understand trucking operations, and policy stability (they are less likely to non-renew you after a single at-fault accident). Minimum premium requirements start around $15,000/year.
Pros: Strongest financial backing in insurance, excellent claims handling reputation, stable renewals without surprise non-renewals, professional underwriting team that understands trucking, A++ AM Best rating. Cons: Higher premiums than competitors, slower quoting process (days not hours), limited online self-service tools, may not accept very new authority. Best for established owner-operators and small fleets who prioritize claims reliability and insurer stability over finding the absolute lowest premium.
#3: Canal Insurance — Best for Small Fleets
Canal Insurance Company has specialized in trucking insurance since 1939, giving them more than 85 years of trucking-specific underwriting experience. Their sweet spot is small fleets of 2-25 trucks, where they offer fleet discounts, combined deductible programs, and fleet safety consulting that help small operators access pricing typically reserved for larger carriers. Canal understands that a five-truck fleet operates differently than a 500-truck carrier, and their underwriting reflects that nuance.
Coverage includes auto liability, cargo, physical damage, general liability, workers' compensation, and umbrella policies up to $5 million. Their loss control program provides free safety assessments, driver training resources, and CSA score monitoring that can reduce both your accident frequency and your premium costs over time. Canal also offers occupational accident coverage for owner-operators classified as independent contractors. Premiums for a small fleet average $8,000-$16,000 per power unit annually depending on equipment type and operational radius.
Pros: 85+ years of trucking specialization, excellent small fleet pricing and discounts, free loss control and safety programs, flexible underwriting for niche operations, occupational accident coverage available, strong claims handling. Cons: Limited availability in some western states, less competitive for single-truck operators compared to Progressive, traditional quoting process requires working through an agent. Best for owner-operators growing from one truck to a small fleet who want an insurance partner invested in their safety and success.
#4: Great West Casualty — Best Safety Incentive Programs
Great West Casualty Company, headquartered in South Sioux City, Nebraska, is the largest insurer of trucking companies in the United States by premium volume. Their focus on trucking — it is the only line of business they underwrite — means every underwriter, claims adjuster, and loss control consultant understands the industry. This specialization shows in their safety incentive programs, which reward drivers and fleets for clean records with meaningful premium reductions and cash bonuses.
Their Drive Safe program tracks individual driver performance and provides financial incentives for accident-free driving periods. Fleet owners can access their safety library of training videos, toolbox talk materials, and compliance checklists at no additional cost. Great West's annual safety awards recognize drivers who achieve multi-year accident-free records, providing recognition that helps with driver retention. Premiums are competitive with the market for experienced operators but they are selective on new authority — typically requiring at least one year of operating history.
Pros: Largest trucking-focused insurer in the US, excellent safety incentive programs, comprehensive loss control resources, strong claims handling with trucking-experienced adjusters, financial rewards for safe driving records. Cons: Generally requires 1+ year of operating authority, less competitive on pricing for new ventures, not available through all independent agents, limited direct-to-customer interaction. Best for established owner-operators and fleets with clean safety records who want to be rewarded financially for maintaining high safety standards.
#5: Sentry Insurance — Best Customer Service
Sentry Insurance consistently earns the highest customer satisfaction ratings in trucking insurance surveys, with their dedicated trucking division providing a level of personal service that larger carriers struggle to match. Each policyholder is assigned a specific service team rather than routing through a call center, which means you speak with people who know your operation, your equipment, and your coverage details without starting from scratch every time you call.
Their trucking coverage suite includes all standard lines plus unique offerings like downtime coverage (pays a daily benefit while your truck is in the shop after a covered loss) and hired auto coverage for operators who occasionally use rented or leased equipment. Sentry also offers bundled business insurance including general liability, property coverage for your shop or yard, and workers' compensation under a single policy with package discounts. Premiums are mid-range — not the cheapest but not premium-priced either. Typical owner-operator policies run $11,000-$18,000/year.
Pros: Best-in-class customer service and responsiveness, dedicated service teams, downtime coverage option, bundled business insurance packages, competitive mid-range pricing, strong financial stability (A+ AM Best). Cons: Smaller agent network than Progressive or Great West, limited online quoting tools, may not be the best fit for very large fleets, less name recognition in trucking. Best for owner-operators who value a personal relationship with their insurance provider and want responsive, knowledgeable service when they need to file a claim or adjust coverage.
How to Shop for Trucking Insurance in 2026
The most important step in buying trucking insurance is working with an independent agent who specializes in trucking — not a general business insurance agent who handles trucking as a side line. A trucking-specialist agent has appointments with multiple carriers on this list and can shop your risk across 5-10 insurers to find the best combination of coverage, pricing, and service. Ask any prospective agent how many trucking policies they write annually — if the answer is under 50, find someone more specialized.
Get quotes from at least three insurers before binding coverage. Provide identical information to each — your USDOT number, MC number, equipment list, driver MVRs, operational radius, and commodities hauled. Compare not just premium but also deductible options (higher deductibles lower premiums but increase your out-of-pocket risk), coverage limits, and exclusions. Pay special attention to cargo coverage exclusions — some policies exclude high-value commodities like electronics, tobacco, or alcohol that you might occasionally haul.
Four factors reduce trucking insurance premiums more than anything else: clean CSA scores (specifically the Unsafe Driving and Crash Indicator BASICs), two or more years of operating authority, a dash camera system (many insurers offer 5-15% discounts), and driver training documentation. Before shopping, pull your CSA scores at the FMCSA website and address any violations or inspections dragging your scores up. A difference of even a few percentile points in your CSA BASICs can mean $2,000-$5,000 in annual premium savings. Compare insurance options alongside other business tools at /compare/dispatch-companies/ and /tools/cost-per-mile-calculator.
Frequently Asked Questions
Find the Right Services for Your Business
Browse our independent reviews and comparison tools to make smarter decisions about dispatch, ELDs, load boards, and factoring.