Responding to Carrier Breakdowns Quickly and Effectively
When a carrier breaks down, the clock starts ticking on multiple problems: the driver is stranded, the load is at risk, and the delivery appointment may be missed. Your response in the first 30 minutes determines whether the breakdown becomes a minor inconvenience or a major crisis. Have a breakdown response protocol that every person in your dispatch operation can execute without hesitation.
Step one is assessing the situation: where is the carrier, what happened, is the driver safe, what is the load (perishable freight has a shorter window than dry goods), and what is the delivery timeline. Step two is coordinating roadside assistance through the carrier's road service provider, your own emergency contacts, or services like FleetNet America that coordinate nationwide truck repair.
Step three is protecting the load. If the repair will take more than four hours and the delivery appointment is at risk, you need a contingency plan. Options include: arranging a relay with another carrier to take over the load, contacting the broker to reschedule the delivery appointment, or in the case of perishable freight, arranging emergency transfer to a functioning reefer unit. Having backup carrier contacts and broker relationships makes step three possible in the moment rather than a frantic scramble.
Recovering from Load Cancellations Without Revenue Loss
Load cancellations happen for many reasons: the shipper's freight is not ready, the broker overbooked capacity, the receiver's dock is full, or market conditions changed. A cancellation costs your carrier the revenue from that load plus the opportunity cost of not having booked an alternative. Your response determines how much revenue is actually lost.
When a load cancels, immediately assess the carrier's current position and available loads in the area. Search the load board before calling the broker to dispute the cancellation so you have alternatives ready. If good options exist, book the replacement load first and then pursue cancellation compensation from the broker afterward. Keeping the carrier moving is the priority.
Pursue TONU (Truck Ordered Not Used) compensation from the broker for every cancellation. The standard TONU fee is $250 to $500, which partially compensates for the revenue loss. Not every broker will pay TONU, but asking for it consistently recovers money that would otherwise be lost. Document the cancellation, the reason provided, the impact on your carrier, and the TONU request in your records.
Managing Detention Situations to Protect Revenue
Detention occurs when a shipper or receiver holds your carrier's truck beyond the agreed free time (typically two hours for pickup and two hours for delivery). Detention costs your carrier $50 to $100 per hour in lost driving time and revenue. As a dispatcher, your job is to minimize detention occurrence and maximize detention pay recovery when it happens.
Document detention from the moment your carrier arrives at the facility. Have your driver note their arrival time, check-in time, and the time loading or unloading begins. Send a text message to yourself with the arrival time as a timestamp. If the free time is exceeded, send a detention notification to the broker immediately: 'Driver arrived at 0800, checked in at 0805, loading has not begun at 1015. Free time expired at 1000. Detention is now accruing at $75/hour per rate confirmation terms.'
Many rate confirmations specify detention terms. Review these terms when booking the load and negotiate detention rates if they are not included. Standard detention rates are $50 to $100 per hour after two hours of free time. If the rate confirmation is silent on detention, your leverage to collect is significantly reduced. Make detention rate inclusion a standard part of your load booking checklist.
Handling Delivery Refusals at Receiver Facilities
A delivery refusal means the receiver will not accept the freight, which leaves your carrier sitting with a loaded trailer and no delivery point. Refusals happen due to: damaged freight, incorrect product, temperature deviations on reefer loads, late delivery outside the appointment window, or paperwork discrepancies. Your immediate response must protect your carrier's time and your broker relationship simultaneously.
First, get the specific reason for the refusal in writing from the receiver. Have your carrier photograph the refusal documentation and the freight condition. Contact the broker immediately with the details and ask for instructions. The broker may direct the carrier to: wait while the shipper contacts the receiver to resolve the issue, deliver to an alternative location, return the freight to the shipper, or store the freight at a nearby warehouse.
Regardless of the outcome, ensure your carrier is compensated for their time and mileage. A refusal that results in a return-to-shipper trip means your carrier drove the delivery route for nothing and now has to drive back. Negotiate with the broker for full payment of the original load plus the return mileage. If the broker refuses, your carrier's broker relationship through your company gives you leverage that an individual driver would not have.
Creating Systems That Prevent Recurring Problems
Every dispatch problem that occurs more than once deserves a preventive system. If your carriers frequently experience detention at specific facilities, note those facilities in your load booking checklist and negotiate detention terms upfront or avoid those facilities altogether. If load cancellations from a specific broker happen repeatedly, reduce your business with that broker or require TONU terms in advance.
Conduct a monthly problem review where you analyze every significant issue from the past 30 days. Categorize problems by type (breakdown, cancellation, detention, refusal, payment, communication), identify the root cause of each, and determine whether a system or process change could prevent recurrence. This continuous improvement approach reduces your problem rate over time and improves carrier satisfaction.
Create a problem resolution database that documents every significant incident: what happened, how you resolved it, what it cost, and what preventive measure you implemented. This database becomes a training resource for new dispatchers and a reference guide when similar situations arise in the future. A new dispatcher who can look up how to handle a reefer breakdown in Oklahoma at midnight provides better service than one who has to figure it out from scratch.
Frequently Asked Questions
Find the Right Services for Your Business
Browse our independent reviews and comparison tools to make smarter decisions about dispatch, ELDs, load boards, and factoring.