Choosing the Right Fuel Card for Your Fleet Size
Fleet fuel cards are not all the same, and choosing the wrong one can cost you thousands per year in missed discounts and unnecessary fees. The three major fuel card networks for commercial trucking are EFS (Electronic Funds Source), Comdata, and WEX/Fleet One. Each has different discount structures, acceptance networks, and fee schedules.
For single-truck owner-operators and very small fleets (1-3 trucks), the TCS Fuel Card and the ATBS Fuel Card offer competitive per-gallon discounts ($0.05-$0.15 off retail at major truck stops) without requiring high volume. These cards are accepted at most Pilot/Flying J, Love's, and TA/Petro locations. The application process is straightforward and does not require a credit check since you prepay or fund the card before use.
For fleets of 5-20 trucks, Comdata and EFS cards offer volume-based discounts that increase with your monthly fuel purchases. At 10,000+ gallons per month, discounts can reach $0.20-$0.40 per gallon at in-network locations. These cards also offer maintenance and tire discounts at participating service centers. The trade-off is higher transaction fees ($1.50-$3.00 per transaction) and more complex account management.
For large fleets (20+ trucks), direct fuel contracts with truck stop chains (Pilot/Flying J AMBEST, Love's Contract, TA Contract) offer the deepest discounts ($0.30-$0.60+ per gallon) but require significant volume commitments. These contracts typically run 12 months and lock in a discount formula based on the OPIS (Oil Price Information Service) rack price plus a negotiated margin.
Regardless of fleet size, compare the net cost per gallon after all discounts and fees. A card offering a $0.20 per gallon discount but charging a $2.50 per transaction fee and a $10 monthly account fee may cost more than a card with a $0.12 discount and no fees. Calculate your actual monthly fuel spend on each card option to find the true lowest cost.
Setting Up Spending Controls to Prevent Misuse
Fuel card fraud and misuse cost small fleets an average of $3,000-$5,000 per year per truck. The most common forms are drivers fueling personal vehicles, purchasing non-fuel items (electronics, merchandise) at truck stops, and sharing card numbers with other drivers. Proper spending controls eliminate these problems.
Set daily and per-transaction fuel limits based on your truck's tank size and expected consumption. A truck with dual 120-gallon tanks should never need more than 250 gallons in a single fueling. Set the per-transaction limit at 260 gallons (allowing for some variation) and the daily limit at 350 gallons (allowing for a second fueling on long-haul days). Any transaction exceeding these limits is automatically declined, and you receive an alert.
Restrict purchase categories to diesel fuel only. Most fuel card platforms let you disable purchases of gasoline, DEF fluid, merchandise, cash advances, and services at the transaction level. If your drivers need to purchase DEF or oil, enable those categories specifically. Every open purchase category is an opportunity for misuse.
Enable vehicle ID prompts that require the driver to enter the truck number or unit number before each transaction. This links every fuel purchase to a specific vehicle, making it easy to cross-reference with GPS data and fuel level readings. Some cards also support odometer prompts, creating a record that you can compare against telematics mileage.
Set geographic restrictions if your trucks operate in defined regions. A fuel card for a truck that runs Texas to Georgia should not work at a fuel station in Oregon. Geographic limits prevent use of lost or stolen cards and immediately flag unauthorized out-of-area fuel purchases. Most platforms let you define geographic zones by state, zip code, or radius around a point.
Integrating Fuel Cards with IFTA Tax Reporting
IFTA (International Fuel Tax Agreement) requires you to report fuel purchased and miles driven in each state quarterly. The manual process of sorting through fuel receipts and matching them to mileage records is tedious and error-prone. Fuel card data automates 80% of this process.
Most fuel card platforms provide IFTA-ready reports that break down fuel purchases by state, date, and quantity. These reports can be downloaded as CSV files and imported directly into IFTA filing software or given to your accountant. The fuel card data shows exactly how many gallons you purchased in each state, which is one of the two data inputs required for IFTA calculations (the other being miles driven per state from your ELD or GPS data).
To maximize IFTA accuracy, ensure every fuel purchase goes on the fuel card rather than being paid with cash or personal credit cards. Cash purchases create gaps in your fuel card data that must be manually reconciled from paper receipts. If a driver must pay cash for fuel (card reader down, non-network location), they should photograph the receipt and submit it the same day so you can add it to the IFTA records.
Cross-reference your fuel card data with your ELD mileage data quarterly before filing. The total gallons purchased should be roughly consistent with total miles driven divided by your fleet's average MPG. If the numbers diverge significantly (much more fuel purchased than expected for the miles driven), investigate potential fuel theft, data entry errors, or a vehicle with a fuel efficiency problem.
Some fuel card providers offer integrated IFTA filing services for an additional $20-$50 per quarter per truck. They combine your fuel card purchase data with mileage data (from their own telematics or imported from your ELD provider) and generate the complete IFTA return. For small fleets without a dedicated accountant, this service saves hours of quarterly paperwork and reduces the risk of filing errors that trigger audits.
Detecting and Preventing Fuel Card Fraud
Fuel card fraud follows predictable patterns that are easy to detect if you monitor the right indicators. The most common fraud method is fueling a personal vehicle or selling fuel to someone else at the pump. This shows up in data as purchases that exceed the truck's tank capacity, purchases at locations far from the truck's GPS position, or multiple purchases in a short time window that exceed what a single truck could consume.
Set up automatic alerts for these suspicious patterns: any single transaction over 300 gallons (most trucks cannot physically take this much), two transactions within 3 hours at different locations that are more than 200 miles apart (physically impossible unless two different people are using the card), and any transaction at a gas station rather than a truck stop (suggesting a personal vehicle is being fueled since gas stations rarely have diesel islands for semis).
Conduct a monthly fuel card audit by comparing total fuel purchases per truck against total miles driven. Calculate the implied MPG by dividing miles by gallons. If a truck shows an implied 4.0 MPG when its telematics reports 6.5 MPG, approximately 38% of the fuel purchased did not go into that truck. This simple calculation catches fraud that individual transaction alerts might miss.
When you identify suspected fraud, act decisively. Disable the card immediately and investigate before confronting the driver. Pull the GPS data, fuel card transaction detail, and fuel level sensor data for the period in question. Document the discrepancy clearly. If the evidence confirms fraud, you have grounds for termination and potentially criminal charges. Many fleet operators recover stolen fuel costs through payroll deduction (where legal) or civil claims.
Prevention is cheaper than detection. Communicate your monitoring capabilities clearly during driver onboarding: "Every fuel transaction is matched against GPS location and fuel level data. Discrepancies are investigated immediately." When drivers know the system catches fraud, most will not attempt it.
Strategies to Maximize Fuel Card Discounts
The difference between paying retail diesel prices and optimizing your fuel card discounts can exceed $0.40 per gallon. On a fleet burning 5,000 gallons per month, that is $2,000 per month or $24,000 per year in savings from simply being strategic about where and how you fuel.
Route your trucks through in-network fuel stops whenever possible. If your fuel card offers the deepest discount at Pilot/Flying J locations and a lesser discount at Love's, build Pilot/Flying J stops into your route plans. Most GPS and routing apps let you filter points of interest by fuel brand, making it easy for drivers to find in-network locations along their route.
Fuel in low-tax states when your route allows it. Diesel taxes vary dramatically by state: Alabama charges $0.29 per gallon while California charges $0.97. If your route passes through a low-tax state, topping off there saves real money. However, remember that IFTA eventually equalizes fuel tax costs across states, so the benefit is primarily the retail price difference, not the tax difference.
Negotiate your fuel card discount annually. If your volume has increased over the past year, contact your fuel card provider and ask for a better discount tier. Bring competitive quotes from other providers. Fuel card companies will often match or beat competitor pricing to retain your account. A 5-minute phone call can add $0.02-$0.05 per gallon to your discount.
Combine fuel card discounts with truck stop loyalty programs. Pilot/Flying J's myRewards program, Love's My Love Rewards, and TA's UltraONE program offer additional per-gallon credits (typically $0.02-$0.05) on top of your fuel card discount. These loyalty credits often go unclaimed by fleet operators who assume the fuel card discount is the only savings available. Make sure every driver is enrolled in the loyalty program at your primary fuel stop chain.
Frequently Asked Questions
Find the Right Services for Your Business
Browse our independent reviews and comparison tools to make smarter decisions about dispatch, ELDs, load boards, and factoring.