Skip to main content

AtoB vs Fuelman: Modern Fuel Card vs Traditional Fleet Card

86Very Good

AtoB

Average Score

VS
77Good

Fuelman

Average Score

Winner: AtoB

Category Breakdown

Technology & UX

AtoB wins
AtoB90
Fuelman72

AtoB is a fintech-first fuel card with a modern app, instant card issuance, and a clean digital experience that feels like using a consumer banking app. Fuelman's technology is dated, with a clunky portal and limited mobile functionality. For tech-savvy owner-operators, AtoB's modern platform is a breath of fresh air compared to legacy fleet card interfaces.

Fee Transparency

AtoB wins
AtoB88
Fuelman70

AtoB markets itself on fee transparency with clear, straightforward pricing and no hidden transaction fees. Fuelman's fee structure can be more complex with potential per-transaction fees, monthly minimums, and other charges that are harder to predict. For carriers who have been burned by surprise fees on traditional fleet cards, AtoB's clarity is a major selling point.

Fuel Discounts

Fuelman wins
AtoB78
Fuelman84

Fuelman has been in the fleet card business for decades and has established deeper discount networks at fuel stations across the country. AtoB's discount network is growing but cannot yet match Fuelman's breadth of negotiated per-gallon savings. For pure fuel cost reduction, Fuelman's established relationships deliver more savings at more locations.

Network Coverage

Fuelman wins
AtoB82
Fuelman86

Fuelman's acceptance network is extensive, covering most fuel stations including many non-truck-stop locations. AtoB is accepted at major truck stops and growing its network, but there are still some locations where Fuelman works and AtoB does not. For drivers who fuel at diverse locations beyond major chains, Fuelman offers more universal acceptance.

Flexibility & Contracts

AtoB wins
AtoB90
Fuelman74

AtoB offers month-to-month terms with no long-term contracts and easy cancellation. Fuelman may require contracts with minimum volume commitments and early termination fees. For owner-operators and small carriers who want to try a fuel card without commitment, AtoB's no-contract model removes risk and allows easy switching if the card does not meet expectations.

Score Summary

CategoryAtoBFuelmanLeader
Technology & UX9072AtoB
Fee Transparency8870AtoB
Fuel Discounts7884Fuelman
Network Coverage8286Fuelman
Flexibility & Contracts9074AtoB
Overall Average8677AtoB

Our Verdict

AtoB wins for owner-operators and small carriers who value transparency, modern technology, and flexibility. Its no-contract model, clean mobile app, and honest fee structure make it the best choice for independent truckers entering the fuel card market or frustrated with hidden fees from traditional providers.

Fuelman is the better choice for established fleets that prioritize maximum fuel discounts and need wide network acceptance. Its deeper discount relationships and broader acceptance network still deliver more raw fuel savings per gallon for high-volume users.

AtoB represents the future of fleet fuel cards — fintech-driven, transparent, and user-friendly. Fuelman represents the established industry infrastructure with proven discounts. Your choice depends on whether you value the modern experience or maximum per-gallon savings.

Frequently Asked Questions

AtoB is a legitimate, well-funded fintech company backed by prominent investors. They process real fuel transactions at major truck stop chains and their card is issued by a licensed bank. While newer than Fuelman, they have established a solid presence in the trucking fuel card market.
Yes, some Fuelman users report per-transaction fees, out-of-network surcharges, and monthly minimum charges that can offset fuel discount savings, especially for low-volume users. Always request a complete fee schedule before signing up and calculate your total cost, not just the advertised discount.
AtoB is generally better for single-truck owner-operators due to its no-contract flexibility, transparent fees, and modern app. Fuelman's discounts are optimized for higher-volume fleets where the per-gallon savings compound more significantly. At lower volumes, AtoB's fee transparency typically results in better net savings.

Need Help Choosing?

Browse our in-depth reviews, use our free comparison tools, and check out our calculators to find the right products for your trucking business.

More Head-to-Head Comparisons

Published March 24, 2026