Skip to main content

Mudflap vs GasBuddy: Fuel Savings App Comparison

86Very Good

Mudflap

Average Score

VS
76Good

GasBuddy

Average Score

Winner: Mudflap

Category Breakdown

Fuel Discounts

Mudflap wins
Mudflap90
GasBuddy72

Mudflap was built specifically for truckers and offers average savings of $0.25-0.50 per gallon at participating truck stops, well above GasBuddy's typical $0.05-0.10 per gallon savings. For a truck fueling 200 gallons, Mudflap saves $50-100 per fill versus $10-20 with GasBuddy. The discount difference is substantial.

Truck Stop Coverage

Mudflap wins
Mudflap85
GasBuddy75

Mudflap focuses on independent and chain truck stops that cater to commercial vehicles. GasBuddy covers more total fuel stations but many are car-oriented locations that truckers cannot easily access. For actual truck-accessible fueling locations, Mudflap's curated network is more relevant.

Ease of Use

Mudflap wins
Mudflap85
GasBuddy82

Both apps are straightforward to use. Mudflap generates a unique code at checkout that applies the discount automatically. GasBuddy's Pay with GasBuddy card provides automatic savings. Mudflap's per-transaction code system works at any participating station without needing a separate payment card, which is simpler.

No Commitment

Mudflap wins
Mudflap92
GasBuddy88

Both apps are free to download and use with no subscription fees or long-term commitments. Mudflap does not require a separate fuel card and works with your existing payment method. GasBuddy's best savings require their payment card. For carriers who want savings without adding another card or commitment, Mudflap is more frictionless.

Fleet Features

Mudflap wins
Mudflap80
GasBuddy65

Mudflap offers fleet management features that let fleet managers track fuel purchases, set driver permissions, and generate expense reports. GasBuddy is designed primarily for individual consumers and lacks meaningful fleet management capabilities. For carriers with multiple drivers, Mudflap's fleet features add genuine administrative value.

Score Summary

CategoryMudflapGasBuddyLeader
Fuel Discounts9072Mudflap
Truck Stop Coverage8575Mudflap
Ease of Use8582Mudflap
No Commitment9288Mudflap
Fleet Features8065Mudflap
Overall Average8676Mudflap

Our Verdict

Mudflap is the clear winner for professional truck drivers due to its significantly deeper fuel discounts, truck stop-focused coverage, and fleet management capabilities. The $0.25-0.50 per gallon savings translates to $5,000-10,000+ annually for a single truck running 100,000+ miles per year.

GasBuddy is a decent consumer app that happens to work at truck stops, but its discounts are modest compared to trucking-specific solutions. Its broader coverage of car-oriented gas stations is irrelevant for most commercial truck drivers.

Every truck driver should download Mudflap. It is free, requires no commitment, and the savings are immediately meaningful. Use it alongside (not instead of) your fleet fuel card, comparing prices to determine which provides the better deal at each fueling stop. Some Mudflap locations will beat your fuel card price; others will not.

Frequently Asked Questions

Mudflap works alongside your fuel card. Compare the Mudflap price versus your fuel card price at each stop and use whichever is cheaper. Some drivers find Mudflap beats their fuel card at independent truck stops while their card is better at chain locations. Having both options maximizes savings.
No, Mudflap discounts are available at participating truck stops. Coverage is growing but not universal. The app shows nearby participating locations and their current discounted prices. Major chains and many independent truck stops participate, but availability varies by region.
Mudflap does not impose gallon limits per transaction. You can fuel 200+ gallons at the discounted price. This makes it practical for Class 8 trucks with large tanks. Always confirm the discount applies to your full purchase amount before fueling.

Need Help Choosing?

Browse our in-depth reviews, use our free comparison tools, and check out our calculators to find the right products for your trucking business.

More Head-to-Head Comparisons

Published March 24, 2026