RigDig vs Highway: Carrier Vetting Platform Comparison
RigDig
Average Score
Highway
Average Score
Category Breakdown
Data Depth
RigDig winsRigDig (from Randall-Reilly) provides deep carrier intelligence including authority history, insurance monitoring, violation patterns, and business associations. Highway focuses more on real-time identity verification and fraud prevention. Both provide FMCSA data but RigDig's historical analytics and pattern detection give it slightly richer data depth.
Fraud Detection
Highway winsHighway has emerged as the industry leader in carrier identity fraud detection, specifically targeting the chameleon carrier and cargo theft problems plaguing the industry. Their real-time identity verification and behavioral analysis tools help brokers identify fraudulent carriers before tendering loads. RigDig provides fraud indicators but Highway's specialized fraud focus is more comprehensive.
Onboarding Speed
Highway winsHighway's automated carrier onboarding can verify and approve new carriers in minutes rather than days. Their digital packet collection and verification streamlines what was traditionally a manual, days-long process. RigDig provides excellent vetting data but the onboarding workflow integration is less automated.
Insurance Monitoring
RigDig winsRigDig provides robust insurance monitoring with alerts when a carrier's coverage lapses or changes. Monitoring insurance status is critical because a carrier with lapsed insurance hauling your freight creates enormous liability. Highway monitors insurance but RigDig's alerts and historical tracking are more detailed.
Ease of Use
Highway winsHighway's modern interface and API-first design make it easy to integrate into existing broker workflows. RigDig's platform is feature-rich but the interface is more complex. For brokerages looking for a tool their team will actually use consistently, Highway's cleaner user experience leads to higher adoption.
Score Summary
| Category | RigDig | Highway | Leader |
|---|---|---|---|
| Data Depth | 85 | 82 | RigDig |
| Fraud Detection | 80 | 92 | Highway |
| Onboarding Speed | 78 | 88 | Highway |
| Insurance Monitoring | 88 | 80 | RigDig |
| Ease of Use | 80 | 88 | Highway |
| Overall Average | 82 | 86 | Highway |
Our Verdict
Highway wins for brokerages primarily concerned with carrier fraud prevention and streamlined onboarding. In an era of rising cargo theft and chameleon carrier activity, Highway's identity verification capabilities address the most urgent security threat in the brokerage industry.
RigDig wins for brokerages that need comprehensive carrier intelligence beyond fraud prevention, including historical authority patterns, insurance monitoring, and deep background analysis. RigDig's data depth supports more informed carrier selection decisions.
Many large brokerages use both platforms complementarily: Highway for real-time fraud screening during onboarding and RigDig for deeper carrier evaluation and ongoing monitoring. The combined cost is modest compared to the potential losses from a single fraudulent carrier interaction.
Frequently Asked Questions
Need Help Choosing?
Browse our in-depth reviews, use our free comparison tools, and check out our calculators to find the right products for your trucking business.
More Head-to-Head Comparisons
Published March 24, 2026